Understanding ERC-404: A New Experimental Token Standard

Back to Blog

Understanding ERC-404: A New Experimental Token Standard

Introduction to ERC-404

ERC-404 is an experimental token standard designed to merge elements of both ERC-20 and ERC-721 token standards, resulting in a token that embodies characteristics of both fungible and nonfungible tokens.

Creation and Development

In February 2024, two pseudonymous developers known as "ctrl" and "Acme" introduced ERC-404, an innovative token standard combining aspects of ERC-20 and ERC-721. Despite the inherent design differences of these two standards, the ERC-404 aims to blend them in a robust manner with minimal tradeoffs, according to its GitHub documentation.

Key Features of ERC-20 and ERC-721

ERC-20 is tailored for fungible tokens, which can be exchanged on a one-to-one basis with other tokens of the same type. This standard allows for the tokens to be divisible into smaller units, enhancing their utility as a medium of exchange.

On the other hand, ERC-721 is used for nonfungible tokens (NFTs), which represent unique, indivisible digital assets or collectibles. Each ERC-721 token is distinct and cannot be exchanged on a one-to-one basis with another ERC-721 token.

Introducing ERC-404

The ERC-404 standard, intriguingly named after the familiar web error code "Error 404," enables NFTs to be fractionalized within the Ethereum network. This is achieved by linking an NFT to a fungible token, allowing fractional ownership.

Pandora: The First ERC-404 Project

The developers of ERC-404 implemented their concept through a project named Pandora, which utilizes the PANDORA token and corresponding "Replicant NFT." Although ERC-404 is not yet an official Ethereum token standard, it operates through smart contracts.

Utility of ERC-404 Tokens

Prior to ERC-404, fractionalizing NFTs was only possible through third-party protocols, which required users to trust these intermediaries to secure their NFTs and accurately reflect their value. ERC-404 eliminates this reliance by using decentralized smart contracts, directly linking the token’s value to the underlying NFT. This method ensures real-time value alignment and removes the need for third parties, thereby enhancing security and accuracy.

ERC-404 tokens enhance liquidity within the NFT ecosystem by enabling users to trade fractional NFTs via liquidity pools governed by smart contracts. When an ERC-404 token is sold, it is equivalent to selling the associated NFT.

Mechanics of ERC-404

ERC-404 employs a "mint-and-burn" mechanism to facilitate fractional ownership and transfer of NFTs. When a complete ERC-404 token is purchased, a smart contract mints a corresponding NFT and assigns it to the buyer's wallet. Conversely, when fractions of an ERC-404 token are sold, the associated NFT is burned, and ownership is transferred to the buyers of those fractions.

Differences Between ERC-20, ERC-721, and ERC-404

ERC-404 distinguishes itself by enabling the fractionalization of NFTs within the Ethereum protocol, fostering shared ownership and liquidity for unique digital assets, unlike the purely fungible ERC-20 or the uniquely identifiable ERC-721 tokens.

Potential Applications of ERC-404

  • Asset Tokenization: Fractional ownership of high-value physical assets like luxury goods, real estate, and artwork becomes more accessible and liquid.

  • Decentralized Finance (DeFi): ERC-404 extends DeFi applications by allowing the use of fractionalized nonfungible assets.

  • Gaming: In-game assets such as avatars and weapons can be fractionalized, enhancing gameplay and accessibility to rare items. Players can trade fractional assets, creating new monetization opportunities.

Challenges Facing ERC-404

  • Official Recognition: ERC-404 lacks official approval from the Ethereum Foundation, raising security and integrity concerns.

  • Experimental Nature: As an experimental standard, ERC-404 carries potential risks and may undergo significant changes, complicating adoption.

  • Market Acceptance: Although gaining initial traction, the long-term stability and acceptance of ERC-404 tokens are uncertain. The value of PANDORA, the first ERC-404 token, has already seen significant fluctuations.

  • Potential Exploits: The nascent stage of ERC-404 presents opportunities for malicious actors to exploit vulnerabilities, posing security risks.

In summary, while ERC-404 offers promising new functionalities by merging fungible and nonfungible token characteristics, it faces challenges related to its experimental status and market acceptance.

Share this article

We use cookies to improve your experience. By closing this message you agree to our Cookies Policy.